The haka has historically been a platform for expressing cultural identity and political messages, particularly in relation to Māori rights.
The controversy highlights the ongoing tensions in New Zealand regarding the Treaty of Waitangi and its implications for contemporary society.
Public opinion is divided, with significant support for Perenara's message among Māori communities, contrasting with criticism from some political leaders.
The ongoing debate may influence future sporting events and the role of athletes in political activism in New Zealand.
Increased public engagement in discussions surrounding the Treaty of Waitangi and its relevance to modern New Zealand society is likely.
Potential changes to the Treaty Principles Bill may arise as a result of the public outcry and protests.
Controversy Erupts Over All Blacks Haka in Turin
The All Blacks' recent performance against Italy in Turin has ignited a significant political controversy back in New Zealand. During the traditional haka, scrum-half TJ Perenara, in his final match for the national team, delivered a poignant message referencing the Treaty of Waitangi, stating, "Toitū te tiriti o Waitangi" which translates to "Pay homage to the Treaty of Waitangi." This statement has sparked a heated debate, particularly among political figures and the public.
Perenara's message was intended to express solidarity with the ongoing protests against the Treaty Principles Bill, which has faced backlash from many in New Zealand. The bill aims to extend the principles of the Treaty of Waitangi, signed in 1840, to all New Zealanders. This has led to widespread protests, with 42,000 people participating in a recent march in Wellington, one of the largest demonstrations in defense of Māori rights in the country's history. Perenara emphasized the importance of unity among all New Zealanders, stating, "To show the unity of our people back home... that was important to us and to me."
Reactions from Political Leaders and the Public
The reaction to Perenara's haka has been mixed. While many Māori leaders and supporters praised his actions as a powerful statement of unity, others, including David Seymour, leader of the libertarian Act Party, criticized the political nature of the haka. Seymour argued that athletes should refrain from political statements during sporting events. In contrast, All Blacks captain Scott Barrett defended Perenara's right to express his views, stating that athletes have the opportunity to convey important messages.
Head coach Scott Robertson supported Perenara's decision, noting that it had been discussed prior to the match and was seen as a sign of unity. Te Pāti Māori co-leader Debbie Ngarewa-Packer also commended the message, asserting that protecting the Treaty is vital for all New Zealanders. The debate continues as New Zealand grapples with the implications of the Treaty Principles Bill and the role of athletes in political discourse.
