Legal Clash Over Police Interference in Israel
The government's legal adviser, Gali Beharev Miara, has appealed to the High Court about National Security Minister Itamar Ben Gvir's 'flagrant violation of the law and improper interference' in police operations. This appeal follows a complaint by Police Commissioner Kobi Shabtai regarding Ben Gvir's involvement in police decisions.
According to a letter from the State Attorney's Office, Ben Gvir's actions were prohibited both before and after the amendment to the police order, and are contrary to court decisions. The letter raises concerns about 'legal ambiguity' and warns that the minister's powers could lead to political influence over police operations, undermining the rule of law and human rights.
One significant instance noted was Ben Gvir's order to Deputy Commissioner Avshalom Peled to stop securing aid convoys to Gaza, bypassing Commissioner Shabtai. This incident was revealed after Shabtai sent a detailed letter to Beharev Miara, citing several cases where Ben Gvir interfered in police work, violating a High Court decision that bars him from issuing operative instructions.
Minister Ben Gvir defended his actions, claiming Commissioner Shabtai was falsifying events and hiding pertinent contexts. He emphasized that his nomination of Superintendent Avshalom Peled for Police Commissioner reflects Peled's experience and qualifications. Ben Gvir reiterated his commitment to addressing what he describes as a 'culture of lying' within the police and intends to respond to the High Court about these allegations.
- The conflict has intensified with both key figures, Commissioner Shabtai and Minister Ben Gvir, standing firm on their grounds. Shabtai insists on protecting the police from political pressures, while Ben Gvir criticizes the current police culture.
- This legal battle underscores the ongoing tension between political authority and law enforcement independence in Israel. The outcome of the High Court's decision could have profound implications for the future dynamics between the Israel Police and governmental influence.
