Knesset Approves Gideon Sa'ar as Minister Without Portfolio in Netanyahu's Government
The Israeli Knesset has officially approved Gideon Sa'ar's appointment as a minister without portfolio in Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's government, a decision that has sparked significant controversy. The vote, held on September 30, 2024, saw 57 members in favor and 40 against, amid heated debates regarding the implications of Sa'ar's inclusion in the cabinet. Sa'ar, leader of the right-wing National Right party, previously withdrew from the emergency government established at the onset of the Gaza war, citing dissatisfaction with his exclusion from key decision-making groups.
In a joint press conference with Netanyahu, Sa'ar stated, "In the current situation, I have concluded that there is no point in continuing to sit in the opposition... This is the time when it is my duty to try to contribute at the decision-making table." His appointment comes in the wake of speculation about his potential replacement of Defense Minister Yoav Galant, further complicating the political landscape as the government faces mounting pressure from opposition parties calling for its resignation.
Opposition Leaders Criticize Sa'ar's Appointment
The reaction from opposition leaders has been swift and scathing. Yair Lapid, the chairman of the opposition, condemned the move as a "political work arrangement of the lowest kind," suggesting that it undermines the integrity of the government during a critical time of conflict. He expressed concerns that this political maneuvering would ultimately harm Israeli soldiers and exacerbate existing tensions within the government.
Lapid's sentiments were echoed by other opposition figures, including Merav Michaeli, who criticized the appointment as a betrayal of principles and a sellout of security interests. Michaeli sarcastically remarked on the supposed unity and victory that Sa'ar's addition was meant to represent, arguing that it instead highlighted the chaotic nature of the current political environment.
Supporters of Sa'ar, however, argue that his entry into the cabinet is a necessary step to influence security policy during ongoing military operations. Sharan Hashakal, a member of Sa'ar's party, defended the decision, stating that it was made to effect change in wartime policies and to address pressing security concerns.
As the Netanyahu government grapples with internal dissent and external pressures, the appointment of Gideon Sa'ar is likely to be a focal point in the ongoing political discourse surrounding Israel's governance during a time of crisis.
