World Daily News
Politics
Israel / Gaza / Middle East

Israeli Writer Advocates Land Confiscation in Gaza to Penalize Hamas: A Controversial Proposal

Images from the reference sources
An Israeli writer proposes a controversial plan to confiscate land from Gaza as punishment for Hamas, sparking debates on morality and consequences. Discover the implications of this proposal.


An armed Israeli settler inside a farm in the Gaza Strip (Getty)

A writer in Yedioth Ahronoth called for punishing the residents of Gaza by confiscating one kilometer of their land for every Israeli prisoner killed in the Strip, and turning it into agricultural land for the benefit of the Israelis.

Ignoring the fact that most of the prisoners held by the resistance in Gaza were killed in Israeli airstrikes, Alon Goldstein said, “There is no doubt that a high price must be imposed on the Palestinians, preferably as soon as possible. The general Israeli response does not diminish the Palestinians’ motivation to repeat the horrific act over and over again, regardless of the deal that will be made with them.”

Punishing the Palestinians with their most precious possession

The writer believed that what hurts the Palestinians the most is the land, unlike the Israelis who care about their lives, according to him.

Accordingly, the writer called for “harming the Palestinians in their most precious possession, which is the land, in return for the harm inflicted on the Israelis in their most precious possession.”

"The land must be taken away, but without getting into the divisive issue of building new settlements, which is also an external problem," he said. "We must create the 'Israeli Agricultural Army.'"

"We must draw a clear and painful line in the sand of the Gaza Strip, which is about 370 square kilometers in area, and a total of 251 Israelis were kidnapped, 70 of whom were killed by Hamas," he claimed.

The writer suggested "cutting off a square kilometer from the Gaza Strip for every kidnapped person and giving it to the army, which would form an army of volunteer farmers, who would work on the (former) Palestinian land and grow seasonal crops such as wheat, barley, oats, corn, watermelon, and clover."

"And more than that," he added. "The entire nation will be able to mobilize for the mission and provide seedlings, equipment and even manpower. The IDF will market these products in the Israeli market at reasonable prices, and the money raised will be able to go back to repairing the envelope, rehabilitating the north and the welfare of the families of the abductees."

"A lesson to our enemies"

The writer went on to explain his idea, which stems from the principle of revenge, saying, “Every square kilometer of crops will be commemorated with the name of a kidnapped person who did not return, whether on signs on the ground or on maps. The Israeli army should leave these areas as a deposit for at least a decade even after the end of the war, in the hope that it will be an insurance policy in our hands as part of the dismantling of Hamas and the release of all the hostages, and that it will distance the residents of Gaza from the walls of the surrounding settlements.”

The writer considered that this step would have a triple positive effect: “It would impose a material, ongoing and clear price on Hamas, as it would harm it more than others; it would impose a material, ongoing and clear price on it; and it would distance the settlers of the Gaza envelope a little from Gaza, without the need to establish new settlements inside the Gaza Strip. In addition, it would perpetuate the memory of the prisoners who were killed.”

“There is another effect, perhaps the most important of all,” he concluded. “We will teach our enemies in the Middle East a lesson. If you kidnap and kill, you will not inherit this land.”

Source: Israeli press

Clam Reports
Refs: | Aljazeera |

Trends

Politics

How to Vote in the 2024 US Election: Key Information and Guidelines

2024-11-05T01:36:57.046Z

As the 2024 US presidential election approaches, this article provides essential information about voting procedures, registration requirements, polling locations, and how to correctly mark your ballot.

Politics

Israeli Analysts Warn of Dire Consequences if Trump Wins 2024 Election

2024-11-05T03:36:54.010Z

Israeli political analysts express concerns that a Trump victory in the upcoming U.S. election could lead to dire consequences for Israel and its foreign relations.

Politics

Trump's Rally Remarks and Poll Predictions Ahead of 2024 Election

2024-11-05T02:26:53.339Z

As the 2024 US election approaches, Donald Trump's controversial rally comments suggest a continued use of aggressive rhetoric, while a new mega-poll indicates a potential victory for Kamala Harris.

Politics

Moldova's Presidential Elections: Maia Sandu's Victory Amid Controversy

2024-11-05T02:06:57.365Z

Maia Sandu wins Moldova's presidential elections amid allegations of electoral manipulation and strong support from the diaspora.

Politics

Muslims Expected to Influence Election Results in Key Battleground States

2024-11-05T03:36:58.355Z

Muslim voters in the U.S. are expected to significantly influence the 2024 presidential election, particularly in seven battleground states, with a historic voter turnout anticipated.

Politics

2024 US Election: Harris Leads Trump in New Polls Amid Foreign Policy Concerns

2024-11-05T03:26:58.270Z

New polling data suggests Kamala Harris is likely to defeat Donald Trump in the upcoming 2024 US election, with significant implications for US foreign policy in the Middle East.

Latest